An architect needs to reduce the budget by $150,000 for a proposed civic auditorium. Currently the project requires the following flooring materials:
Stained concrete: 100,000 square feet
Carpet: 50,000 square feet
Ceramic tile: 20,000 square feet
Vinyl composite tile (VCT): 25,000 square feet
The flooring material costs are as follows:
Stained concrete: $6.00/sq ft
Sealed concrete: $2.00/sq ft
Carpet: $8.75/sq ft
Ceramic tile: $15.00/sq ft
VCT: $5.75/sq ft
Vinyl plank flooring: $7.00/sq ft
Which of the following combinations of changes results in these savings?
Verified Answer: C. Change 20,000 sq ft of stained concrete to VCT and substitute 10,000 sq ft of VCT for
Comprehensive Detailed Explanation with all NCARB ARE 5.0 Project Development and Documentation (PDD) Study Guide Reference:
Calculate savings for each option by comparing current costs to proposed changes.
Verified Answer: C. Change 20,000 sq ft of stained concrete to VCT and substitute 10,000 sq ft of VCT for
Comprehensive Detailed Explanation with all NCARB ARE 5.0 Project Development and Documentation (PDD) Study Guide Reference:
Calculate savings for each option by comparing current costs to proposed changes.


Check if this matches required savings:
No, it's less than $150,000. So let's check others briefly.

Options A and B will be less, so the answer should be D.
Summary:
Option D results in approximately $152,500 savings, meeting the $150,000 target.
NCARB ARE 5.0 Review Manual, Project Cost Control and Materials chapter
Construction cost estimating principles and value engineering strategies
Change 20,000 sf stained concrete ($6.00/sf) to VCT ($5.75/sf)
Savings per sf = $6.00 - $5.75 = $0.25
Total savings = 20,000 sf $0.25 = $5,000
Substitute 10,000 sf of VCT ($5.75/sf) for ceramic tile ($15.00/sf)
Savings per sf = $15.00 - $5.75 = $9.25
Total savings = 10,000 sf $9.25 = $92,500
Total savings = $5,000 + $92,500 = $97,500
Check if this matches required savings:
No, it's less than $150,000. So let's check others briefly.
Option D:
Change 25,000 sf stained concrete ($6.00/sf) to sealed concrete ($2.00/sf)
Savings per sf = $6.00 - $2.00 = $4.00
Total = 25,000 4.00 = $100,000
Substitute 30,000 sf vinyl plank ($7.00/sf) for carpet ($8.75/sf)
Savings per sf = $8.75 - $7.00 = $1.75
Total = 30,000 1.75 = $52,500
Total savings = $100,000 + $52,500 = $152,500 Meets and exceeds required savings
Options A and B will be less, so the answer should be D.
Summary:
Option D results in approximately $152,500 savings, meeting the $150,000 target.
NCARB ARE 5.0 Review Manual, Project Cost Control and Materials chapter
Construction cost estimating principles and value engineering strategies
